Mastering "We Loved Once and True" in Red Dead Redemption 2

Welcome, fellow gamers! 🎮 If you are diving into the rich and immersive world of Red Dead Redemption 2, you’ll want to ace the emotional mission titled "We Loved Once and True." This pivotal quest not only showcases the heart-wrenching story of Arthur Morgan, Mary Linton, and Jamie, but also comes with a Gold Medal checklist that can enhance your gaming experience. Let’s saddle up and get going! 🌟

Objectives of "We Loved Once and True"

To ensure you complete the quest successfully, keep the following objectives in mind:

1. Peacefully convince the Chelonians to let you take Jamie

2. Return Jamie to Mary within 2 minutes 

This mission marks a significant emotional turning point in the game, giving players a chance to make impactful choices.

---

How to Complete "We Loved Once and True"

Step 1: Initiate the Quest

To start your journey in "We Loved Once and True," locate and read the letter at your camp desk. This letter from Mary Linton, Arthur’s past love, beckons you to reunite. She’s still reeling from her husband’s death and is desperate for help regarding her brother, Jamie.

Pro Tip: The quest is available only after completing "The First Shall Be Last," so plan accordingly!

Step 2: Head to Mary’s Location

Mary is staying at a house just north of Valentine. Consult your map and make your way there. When you knock on the door, be prepared for a surprise! A woman opens the door with a gun, but soon brings out Mary after knowing who you are.

Step 3: Understand the Situation

Mary shares that her brother Jamie has joined a peculiar religious sect called the Chelonians. Despite the complicated history between Arthur and Mary—where they almost got married—Arthur ultimately decides to help her in the mission. Your choice here influences the story, so choose wisely! ❗

Step 4: Approach the Chelonians

Once you agree to help Mary, you'll find a marker directing you to Cumberland Forest. This is where you will encounter the Chelonians. They will appear hostile, and it’s crucial to manage this situation peacefully to meet the Gold Medal requirement.

- To negotiate for Jamie’s release, use the dialogue options:

  - “Undecided”

  - “Purpose” 

Successfully negotiate, and Jamie will hop on a horse, making his escape. Here’s where your adventure gets even more exciting! 🏇

Step 5: The Chase

Follow Jamie closely, as he will likely dash to the other side of some train tracks. He will threaten to shoot himself, creating a tense moment.

Tip for Gamers: When it’s time to disarm him without causing serious harm, gently press R2 to aim. This will help you master various showdown scenarios in the game. Aim specifically at Jamie’s arm to ensure he drops the weapon without harm.

Step 6: Return Jamie to Mary

Once Jamie drops his weapon, it's time to make a dash to the train station! Keep an eye on your map and move swiftly; you have only 2 minutes to get him back to Mary to secure that Gold Medal status.

Upon reaching the station, you’ll witness a touching reunion as Jamie and Mary reunite, boarding the train and leaving Arthur behind. 🌄

---

Conclusion

Completing "We Loved Once and True" not only boosts your gaming achievements but also imparts a meaningful story that resonates with players. By following this comprehensive guide, you’ll navigate the emotional dynamics of Arthur, Mary, and Jamie while fulfilling mission objectives. Enjoy the journey, and happy gaming! 🐎✨